Skip to main content

Part 3 ~ Miracles: An Answer to Hume

There is a gap between the probable and the proved. How was I to cross it? If I were to stake my whole life on the risen Christ, I wanted proof. I wanted certainty. I wanted to see him eat a bit of fish. I wanted letters of fire across the sky. I got none of these.1
~Sheldon Vanauken 

Recap. We last discussed a bit of what David Hume believed or did not believe about the occurrence of miracles. In this post, we will look at an opposing viewpoint to Hume's position. These posts are not exhaustive on this topic, nor are they intended to be. The purpose of these posts on Miracles is to cause us to ponder some thought provoking questions many have wrestled with over the years. 


photo credit: Thomas Hawk via photopin cc
An Objection. Thomas Sherlock, author of Tryal of Witnesses, presented a mock trial where the apostles are accused of hoaxing the resurrection of Jesus. During the trial it is argued that because the resurrection was a violation of nature, and therefore eyewitness testimony to the resurrection could not establish the resurrection as fact. The argument that the resurrection violated the law of nature in presented in Sherlock's work, mirrored the arguments of Hume. In summation, Sherlock held the view that it was absurd to believe that facts in question could not be proved by testimonial evidence. Further, Sherlock argued that the resurrection did not violate nature. Rather, Sherlock makes the argument that we as humans observe nature and how it has behaved for us in the past; to assume that it will continue behaving as it has in the past, originate with the "prejudices and imaginations of men."2

Parting Thought. Many contemporaries of Hume considered him a deist; that is, one who believes that God created the world but "denies his (God's) supernatural intervention in it on the grounds that the world operates by natural and self-sustaining laws of the Creator."3


If we believe that God created the world and formed it ex nihilo ('out of nothing") then why would we not believe or think the Creator could not or would not intervene with His creation? After all, wasn't creation a miracle in and of itself?




1 Alister E. McGrath, Intellectuals Don't Need God & Other Modern Myths [Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House,  1993], 59.
2 William Lane Craig,Reasonable Faith [Illinois: Crossway, 2008], 254-255. 
3 Norman L. Geisler, Christian Apologetics [Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1976], 151.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What Does Your "Busyometer" Read?

"And they continued steadfastly in the apostles' doctrine and fellowship, and in breaking of bread, and in prayers.Acts 2:42 (KJV)Life can get very busy and the speed at which we function can quickly accelerate to one where we feel we have completely lost control.  We need to slam on the brakes!  How do we stop the proverbial hamster wheel and come up for air?

Recognize the Posted Speed Limit. We must recognize the speed to which we have been called.  And yes, there are times in our lives when the speed seems incredibly fast and we cannot slow down; the truth is, some seasons in life are like that.  However, there are other times in our lives when we must eliminate those activities that were not put upon us by God, but rather our own doing for myriad reasons.



Adjust Your Speed. Once we realize who we are and what God is calling us to do, we are then required to adjust our speed.  Look at what the multitudes did upon hearing Peter speak: 1) they gave their lives to Christ…

Tired of the TO DO Lists?

The Great Grind: If you're anything like me, your life is filled to overflowing with the necessities and then some!  I'm sure you have a life filled with the daily grind of shopping, cooking, cleaning, working, going to the Doctor, going to the bank, running to the pharmacy, taking care of the sick pet, thinking of meals for the upcoming week, taking care of the children, and if you home school your children - lesson planning, grading, teaching, gathering material and then there's paying the bills, cutting coupons to save money, and oh yes, the beloved laundry!  And the defining moment when you realize you do not have any clean underwear for the next morning...ugh.  


The Great Grind photo credit: Informedmag writing business plans - Credit to informedmag.com via photopin(license)
The Great Loss:So, I highlighted some things that are probably common to most of us in the daily grind but there is one VERY important piece I failed to mention.  Our relationship with the Lord is of…

Part 2 ~ Miracles: Impossible?

And behold, you will conceive in your womb and bear a son, and you shall name Him Jesus.  Luke 1:31 Miracles: Impossible? Remembering David Hume's definition of a miracle from the last post: "[a] violation of the laws of nature; and because firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the case against a miracle is--just because it is a miracle--as complete as any argument from experience can possibly be imagined to be." 1 If we take a look at Hume's definition of miracle, at first glance, it would seem as if he is declaring miracles to be an impossibility because they cannot violate the laws of nature. Is this really what Hume is attempting to argue? Hume taught "that what we call the laws of nature are simply an account of what has happened up to the present plus a belief that the future will continue to be like the past."2 According to Hume, we observe what has happened and we believe, or shall we say, take a step of faith to believe that wha…

Google+ Followers

BG Badge

BG Badge
Bible Gateway Blogger